Imagine…a new engagement officer joins your team. In their first two months, they have already had at least one point of contact with each of the 1,000 people in their portfolio and increased giving from those constituents over the previous year.
This is not fantasy, but it is a bit of science fiction becoming reality.
AI has been the topic of conversation at every conference I have attended over the last two years, but I am always left with the same two questions. What are you using, and how are you using it?
When AI Starts Talking to Donors
Advancement professionals I talk to often share that they are using AI to save time on tasks like reporting and data analysis, or utilizing tools like ChatGPT, Claude, and Copilot for writing support and content creation. While many of the advancement technology solutions on the market offer AI integrations and insights, a few bold companies are offering AI agents that communicate directly with alumni and donors.
In a recent conversation with a vice president for development, I asked whether they would consider using an AI agent to engage the thousands of unassigned donors they have in their prospect pool. Her response was, “Absolutely NOT, our alumni would revolt!”
It can feel like a huge leap to go from using AI to draft an email to adopting an agent that reaches out directly to alumni on behalf of the institution. Yet there are more alumni and prospective donors in our CRMs than the team can reach, making individualized outreach all but impossible.
AI agents act on insights about alumni and donor behavior and allow teams to engage alumni and unassigned prospects who would otherwise only receive standardized messages.
Despite being a Xennial (that microgeneration between Gen X and Millennials), I consider myself an early adopter of technology, so I am curious to learn more.
Earlier this month, I talked with Garrett Holland, Director of Annual and Leadership Giving at Midwestern State University in Wichita Falls, Texas. It also happens to be my grandparents’ alma mater. MSU Texas is a public university with more than 5,000 students and 44,000 alumni. They have a small advancement team, and until recently, Vice President for University Advancement Jeff Spoeri served as their lone major gifts officer.
Meet Mara - Midwestern State University’s Virtual Engagement Officer
In September, MSU Texas launched their Virtual Engagement Officer (VEO), Mara, to reach more alumni and expand their donor pipeline as they continue building their major gift staff. Having talked to several vendors, the primary reason MSU Texas chose the Virtual Engagement Officer (VEO) by Version2.ai powered by Givzey was the visual avatar that personifies the agent and provides a more human-centered experience. The company now has more than 250 autonomous fundraising agents deployed across the country and have enabled $20M+ in contributions.
The goal is not to deceive alumni by making them think they are talking to a human. Transparency is incredibly important, and constituents are told they are communicating with an AI agent and can opt out and even opt in to the program.
Clean data was critical to successful implementation, but it wasn’t necessary to have clean data for all the records in the CRM to get started. For the initial portfolio, Garrett worked with the prospect management and research team to identify around 1,000 current donors and undergraduate alumni who demonstrated engagement with the university. For each of those records, they ensured they could easily map more than 20 data points, including updated phone and email contact information and permissions, giving history, birthday, information about class year, athletic interest, student activity participation, and other information the agent can use to initiate a conversation.
Mara is powered by data provided about the portfolio and the knowledge base (“the brain”) developed by the team and interacts in a way that spurs conversation by sharing information and asking questions that encourage constituents to respond. However, the VEO is not connected to the CRM and can only draw on information imported to the assigned portfolio and approved resources stored in the knowledge base. He shared that they can simply forward emails, newsletters, articles, and other information about the University to “the brain” to expand the information Mara can access to inform conversations. Through regular data imports and exports, they can refresh the agent’s portfolio and record interactions and key information in the constituent’s record in the CRM.
Garrett receives weekly reports about Mara’s activities, including sample interactions. If the exchange advances beyond Mara’s knowledge base, it is flagged and Garrett can intervene by reaching out promptly to the alumnus directly to answer their questions or advance a gift. The level of discernment appears to be sophisticated and allows a human to step in if a question goes unanswered or if a message raises upset or concern.
The Conditions for Success
I think it is important to note that successful implementation of a program like this, even as a pilot, requires an ecosystem that is ready to embrace the emerging technology. In addition to clean data and an enthusiastic champion, there needs to be support from university leadership and AI and data governance policies in place.
In my conversation with Garrett, he shared that the Vice President, Jeff, was supportive of exploring the VEO and actively championed the project to the university leadership team in their regular meetings. Garrett’s enthusiasm and due diligence gave Jeff and other leaders confidence that the new program would enhance engagement and have a measurable return on investment.
Additionally, MSU Texas spent more than a year developing its AI Strategic framework that outlines clear expectations for AI use by faculty and students, specifically as it relates to teaching and learning. While the framework does not address AI usage by staff, it does signal that the campus is having important conversations about data privacy, responsible use, and accountability.
Early Returns
Garrett and the advancement team at MSU Texas are excited about the results so far. In just two and a half months, Mara has had at least one point of contact with each of the 1,000+ constituents in the portfolio and helped increase giving from those donors by more than $30,000 over last fiscal year. So far, opt-out rates have been low. They are also finding that older alumni are more likely to engage than recent graduates. Givzey CEO, Adam Martel, said in a Chronicle of Philanthropy article last year that people aged 50-70 rank first in engagement even though they expected younger generations to be more open to outreach from AI agents. This is in contrast with research about how older adults engage with AI chatbots in other commercial applications and is worth exploring how this technology is different.
Universities that have introduced VEOs and other AI agents are clear that, with large pools of unassigned current and potential donors, their strategy is not to replace current staff. The goal is to expand staff capacity, build a pipeline of future major donors, and enhance the alumni and donor experience. While the agents are autonomous, the Version2.ai platform ensures that the “human in the loop” remains the authority and can steer the agent when necessary.
As a former student caller, I know firsthand how effective direct outreach can be in acquiring new donors, renewing support, and stewarding current donors. The old phone center model has changed dramatically over the last few years, incorporating more digital engagement, but still requires significant human resources. VEOs don’t necessarily replicate the phone center experience, but they do offer highly personalized outreach that allows alumni and donors to engage on their own terms, replying when it suits them and sharing only as much as they want.. They can even request an introduction to a human fundraiser, an action that might not happen if someone had to go to the website and hunt for an email address. I am excited about how this new technology supports our work, and I am curious to see the results from schools that are further along in their implementation.
How would your institution and alumni respond if an autonomous fundraiser joined your team?

Courtney Stombock’s career has spanned 25 years and two continents, working in many facets of advancement at public and private institutions in the US, UK, and France. At The American University of Paris, Courtney and her team are rethinking what it means to engage and secure philanthropic investment from culturally diverse and diasporic alumni, families, and friends.





Great thought provoking piece Courtney. Great to draw light on agentic capabilities in Advancement and where things are moving.
Protecting alumni goodwill would be an important consideration for me i.e. consult and pilot with alumni first to reduce the risk of a backlash... nobody wants the goodwill drain, "unsubscribe me and never contact me again!" or of course, any reputation damage. And, if some don't want to be involved, that's where the opt out and the governance aspects come in.
Some will love the personalisation and novelty, others will associate it with the narrative that AI is going to be the ruination of the human species. Same as always... you cant please everyone, but as we know, as Advancement practitioners we must be inclusive and respect the many wonderfully diverse members in our community and all their views. The skill is in the execution, and the management and full consideration of risk prior.