For the capstone of his Faculty-in-Residence, Dr. Jay Dillon (UC Berkeley) joined Ryan Catherwood for a live roundtable on alumni identity, with guest hosts Simone Jackson (USC Alumni Association) and Eryn Giegel (Roanoke College) bringing the questions.
Jay’s core argument: alumni identity is the degree to which being a graduate is part of who you are now — and it’s the self, not the school, that predicts behavior. He drew a clean line between the terms we use loosely: pride is about the school, loyalty is about the relationship, and identity is about the self. An alum can wear the sweatshirt every Saturday and never give — that’s pride, maybe loyalty, but not identity.
A few highlights:
“Alumni don’t engage with institutions — they engage with themselves.” Rooted in role identity theory, Jay explained that when an invitation matches how an alum already sees themselves, it “hits different.” When it doesn’t, it falls flat.
Why our metrics mislead: “The cheaper it is for an alum to do something, the less it tells you about who they are.” Email opens and clicks are cheap signals; showing up to an event costs something. Jay even owned that his own early research pointed to email clicks — and that with 10x the data across 11 schools over a decade, it didn’t hold up.
Belonging is a choice. Building on David Hale’s line that “affiliation is a fact, belonging is a choice,” Jay framed the Alumni Identity Score as a way to measure that choice — across three dimensions: salient, social, and role.
Identity is upstream of giving. Traditional models predict from past behavior and find “yesterday’s donors” — blind to first-gen, young, and never-asked alumni. Identity is additive: it helps find tomorrow’s donors.
The engagement gap. The live audience (and the panel) took the 60-second quiz at alumniidentity.com/score. Ryan landed “high identity” — matching the data that ~52% of high-identity alumni give, which means ~48% don’t. That gap, plus the ~30% giving below potential (mostly alumni in their mid-30s), is the real opportunity: people “living in joyful anonymity,” primed to give, that our dashboards can’t see.
What to do: activate the identity that’s already there, avoid eroding it with mismatched asks, and invest upstream with student affairs and career services — because identity is mostly formed while students are still on campus.
Jay closed with a “magic wand” idea: add the word alumni wherever institutions write “students, faculty, and staff” — so graduates see themselves as part of the community from day one.
The identity-first model is being published in the Journal of Philanthropy and Education this month, and the full session will hit the podcast feed soon.
FIR recap primarily generate by AI










