Speaking Engagement
Speaking Engagement (Members)
Louis Diez: Belonging Comes Before the Gift
0:00
-35:00

Louis Diez: Belonging Comes Before the Gift

The flipped expectation reshaping fundraising, and why belonging has to come before the gift.

The challenging dynamic Louis Diez describes in the Keynote this week is that big institutions are losing donors by the bucketload, and he thinks the reason is a flipped expectation most advancement shops haven’t caught up to. Alumni now want to feel connected first and give second, while we still mostly wait for the gift and then offer the connection. There’s no clever way around that gap. When people ask him how to tweak the messaging so alumni feel differently about them, his answer is blunt: “there ain’t no trick.” You either put in the real, costly effort to know people and make them feel known, or you don’t.

Watch the full-length version on YouTube

What I’ve been thinking about is the actual engine of giving, which is community and belonging, not the ask. Louis worries we’ve lost the civic fabric that used to carry philanthropy, the Rotary clubs and class committees and standing groups, and that development offices no longer have the muscle to build it. His most useful reframe is to stop forcing communities where we wish they were and start working with the “phantom communities” already forming on their own, around athletics, around a beloved professor who still hosts the dinners. Belonging is the thing that lasts, and the gift follows it. We just keep trying to do it in the wrong order.

Big Themes This Week

  • The expectation flipped: people want to belong before they give

  • There’s no messaging trick that replaces genuine effort

  • Work with the communities already forming, don’t force new ones

Team Discussion Questions

  • Do we still ask for the gift before we have offered any real connection?

  • Where are the phantom communities already forming that we could support instead of fight?

  • What would it take to build one community well over three years, not ten in a quarter?

Keynote summary generated primarily by AI

Discussion about this episode

User's avatar

Ready for more?